That’s all water under the bridge. It’s same as with Reiser4 Posted Nov 12, 9: It’s might be quite a problem for Linux as a platform when developers with such access to the hardware specs as Markus can’t even properly contribute to the mainline kernel driver. The fact that Markus clearly intended to have some of that code appear in the form of binary-only blobs did not help his case. Is it actually a requirement for driver inclusion that future support be lined up?
|Date Added:||18 September 2015|
|File Size:||47.38 Mb|
|Operating Systems:||Windows NT/2000/XP/2003/2003/7/8/10 MacOS 10/X|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
But, as things stand now, it would empua that this driver is not headed for the mainline. At that stage device node locking, preventing dvb appications to use the nodes while analog TV was in use was already implemented, and I also worked out alot other PCI devices some are still not merged with mainline. There were code quality issues too, of course, but I’m not sure anyone emppia as far as looking at those.
EM28xx cards list — The Linux Kernel documentation
It’s same as with Reiser4 Posted Nov 14, In such cases, the long-term goal is usually to work toward the removal of one of the drivers. Posted Nov 15, 5: So the user-space approach, like its predecessor, was not merged. Obviously, this hasn’t worked out very ej28xx in this instance.
Messages to me from Markus threatening to take his code closed-source if he didn’t get his way didn’t exactly encourage me to support it either. In the end, some of the developers decided to just improve the version of the driver currently in-kernel rather than continuing to deal with Markus. But rejecting Markus’s new driver out of hand might just be a mistake.
The sad story of the em28xx driver Posted Nov 12, The userspace driver attempt. Building a virtual front between developers who actually supported linux for a long time isn’t healthy.
So it is not entirely surprising that this driver has not been received with a great deal of enthusiasm.
Until now I have seen no attempts to make these changes, alas. Also quite a few bugs have been fixed in the kernelframework eg tuner-core it cost alot time all together and the work didn’t get valued at all. The sad story of the em28xx driver Posted Nov 24, Back then Greg Kroah pointed out that binary drivers could use that interface, it was accepted because he basically didn’t clash with another developer. Meanwhile, this driver contains the result of years of ekpia and access to the relevant data sheets; freezing it out may not be in the best interests of kernel developers or users.
The sad story of the em28xx driver Ekpia Nov 12, 0: Meanwhile, the other developer added the main required feature support for hybrid analog-digital tuners to the Video4Linux code in roughly the same way as they’d proposed earlier, but written from scratch, and this was accepted. This attempt to exercise control over freely-licensed code was slapped down by Andrew Morton and others, but it left unpleasant memories behind.
This driver works with a number of video acquisition devices based on Empia chips; many of those are not supported by the kernel now. At the beginning of hybrid devices came up and I continued to work on the driver.
Basically there are too many good people involved already. So at the end the code basically just got left behind and also during the development noone of those people who were against it was interested to join the core development – I asked several time on IRC, the ML posts fm28xx get further anyway either.
In my opinion it’s pretty much hopeless trying to convert the current em28xx driver into what you have. By Jonathan Corbet November 11, Posted Nov 16, It’s same as with Reiser4 Posted Nov 12, 9: Best would be to replace you as a maintainer since you don’t have any respect of others work either.
The sad story of the em28xx driver
He then continued development of the code, hosting it on his own server. It’s might be quite a problem for Linux as a platform when developers with such access to the hardware specs as Markus can’t even properly contribute to the mainline kernel driver.
Experience with drivers merged under this policy has generally been positive; once those drivers head for the mainline, they get more attention and tend to improve quickly.
Posted Nov 13, 1: The drivers which everything was about dmpia still not available in the kernel, it basically was about Micronas chips back then.